Reviews. Electronic thermometers: which is better?

Electronic devices cover different segments of consumer goods. Medical equipment along with the military-defense complex is more active than other industries adopting new technologies. Digital versions of the usual technology, of course, are not something special, but their appearance has significantly changed the nature of the operation in the direction of increasing convenience, as evidenced by user feedback. Electronic thermometers in form resemble traditional mercury models, but the way of providing results is based on liquid crystal displays. However, the market presents many versions of this device, which differ in different characteristics.

Features of electronic thermometers

Many experts recommend switching from traditional glass thermometers to electronic analogues. As a rationale for this advice, there is a known risk of damage to the hull, which entails the evaporation of mercury. Nevertheless, in addition to this danger, the usual thermometer has almost no shortcomings. These are waterproof and anti-allergenic devices, which are also convenient to use. But also an electronic thermometer, reviews of which many operational advantages mark, will be useful in the home medicine cabinet. Such models are good for their speed and absolute safety, from the point of view of ecology.

But the main difference between the two concepts lies in the accuracy of the measurements. The fact is that the glass thermometer shows itself well in working with dynamic indications, allowing to reliably assess the patient's condition. Strange as it may seem, technological digital devices can not boast of the same quality of measurements, which, again, is confirmed by conflicting reviews. Electronic thermometers are less dependent on external influences, but the principle of determining the temperature regime by means of a special conductor assumes a high error margin.

Varieties of models

There are conventional wired electronic models, infrared and non-contact. In each case, their own operating characteristics and nuances of measurements are assumed. Also it is necessary to take into account the classification of devices at the place of measurement - for example, there are oral models, frontal modifications, axillary, etc. It is necessary to make an amendment to the age. For example, an electronic thermometer for a newborn has its own peculiarities, which are expressed in a compact body and more durable body materials. By the way, there are original models for kids, reminiscent of the usual pacifier. This option is attractive not only for stylistic execution, but also for ease of use, as the child willingly agrees to measure a device that is familiar in form. It should be noted that infrared modifications are widely used in all categories, although they do not allow achieving high accuracy, but in a number of cases it is simply impossible to replace them. Such models with a non-contact measuring method, in particular, can become a rescue in the conditions of the sanitary zone.

Comments about Omron models

It is one of the most famous manufacturers of modern thermometers, which produces instruments in several series. At once it is necessary to note rather modest parameters of accuracy, which this electronic thermometer demonstrates. Omron's reviews are criticized for their high error rate, but in most cases the incorrectness of the indication is due to improper use of the device.

The fact is that the models of this brand provide for the delivery of an appropriate signal after the measurements are made. But just at this moment a general measurement of the state takes place. To obtain the necessary data, it is necessary to keep the working element for at least 5 minutes. The rest is marked by a rather high quality of the device. For example, many praise the ergonomics and reliability of the case, which houses an electronic thermometer "Omron". The feedback is underscored by a convenient system for providing measurement results.

Model Reviews B.Well

Criticism of thermometers of this brand largely corresponds to the products described above. Although the manufacturer indicates the measurement interval within 60 seconds, in practice it is possible to obtain temperature data only after a few minutes. It must be said that this time is also quite competitive, as even professional devices rarely provide a higher speed. But even if you do not take into account the errors in the measurement technique, many note the fairly average accuracy, which shows the electronic thermometer B.Well. Reviews of a large part of the owners of such devices are distinguished and many advantages. For example, models are praised for the presence of moisture-resistant coatings, the absence of hammering and other potentially dangerous elements in the design, as well as the possibility of saving measurement results.

Reviews of models Gamma

The company offers multifunction devices that can be used for both children and adults. Virtually all versions of Gamma thermometers provide for the possibility of oral, rectal and axial measurement, for which many users praise this electronic thermometer. The reviews also note that the measurement process as such starts rather quickly, but only ends in a few minutes, which is not always convenient. But mercury models also perform their function on average 5-10 minutes. An exception may be infrared modifications, which are also represented in the Gamma line. Such versions perform almost instantaneously, but the accuracy of the readings leaves much to be desired.

Comments about Microlife models

Such models are quite massive in comparison with competitive products, but in exchange for this lack the user receives an accurate measurement. As noted by the reviews, Microlife's electronic thermometers require more time to stop, but in the end they provide data similar in accuracy to mercury analogues. That is, in terms of ergonomics this is not the best option, but if truthful data is important with a minimum error, then it is worthwhile to refer to the products of this brand. Moreover, it costs less than electronic graders from the above-mentioned manufacturers.

How to choose the best option?

The choice should be based on several characteristics, among which accuracy of measurement, functionality and convenience. As practice shows, accuracy is the weak point of many electronic thermometers. But, to track the dynamics, it may not be required. In some cases, users simply make a correction for the error, getting a more objective result. Anyway, if the correctness of the readings is important, then it is necessary to apply to Microlife models. This is a good electronic thermometer, reviews of which also underscore its reliability and durability. If an ergonomic and multifunctional model is required, which will be convenient to use outside of the home, it makes sense to refer to Omron or B.Well products. These are not just convenient and attractive externally, but also environmentally friendly devices.

Recommendations for the use of thermometers

In no small measure, the accuracy of the readings depends on the tightness of the functional part to the skin. As already noted, immediately after the production of the audio signal, it is not worth reading. It is necessary not to forget the characteristic of the "temperature", which is available for each electronic thermometer. Reviews, instructions and the doctors themselves recommend leaving the device in the working position for at least 5 minutes. This will provide more accurate data at the output. It should also be taken into account that digital models are powered by battery power. Since the activation of the charge occurs just at the time of use, it must be strictly monitored, so that the final failure of the batteries does not occur at the most crucial moment.

Conclusion

Most of the electronic thermometers are designed for construction in difficult conditions. Devices can be taken on the road without fear that they will break and lose the ability to perform their functions. For example, waterproof and shockproof models are quite common, the reliability of which is confirmed by the feedback. Electronic thermometers are also convenient from the point of view of measuring technique. Contrary to advertising announcements about the high speed of measurements, in practice, only preparation of the device for work is performed quickly. Unless infrared devices are able to really surprise with their speed, but the quality of such a result suits a few. However, standard digital devices do not take much time either. After the sound indication it remains to hold the device for 5-6 minutes, after which temperature data will be provided. Depending on the modification, the devices can use the obtained data for statistics, which may be required for long-term observations.